PR Start by Nick Lucido

How to start in the public relations industry.
July 2, 2009

Bad Idea, Ad Agency Intern

Posted by : nicklucido

trump

This morning as I was going through my e-mail inbox at work, I happened to see this article on an intern who resigned from her company. Basically, Jenavi Kasper worked at an advertising agency in Phoenix for three weeks and quit because she had higher expectations for working there. I’m not kidding. I recommend checking out the comments on the post — some defend and some attack. I side with the latter.

First, I’ll add that as a fellow intern, I can’t say I can relate to Jenavi. In my four work experiences since I’ve been in college, I’ve had four incredible experiences that have taught me a lot of public relations. Then again, if I were in her shoes, I would do things a little bit differently.

So, here are my points as to what Jenavi did wrong. I hope you can find some value in learning from these.

  • Give it time. Somewhere in the comments, it was mentioned that she only worked three weeks (two days per week, at that) at the agency. That’s one business week and one day. It’s important to remember how agencies operate: they hire when they win business, fire when they lose it and are always in a state of adapting to a new balance of clients. Interns should spend some time learning and asking questions before they join in on this cycle be the most beneficial to the agency. That takes time and patience. It seems as though neither were present in this situation.
  • Her expectations were way off. I’ve now worked at three public relations agencies and I’ve been able to do some pretty cool things. However, I’ve also answered phones, moved boxes, delivered fliers to 100+ people in person… you get the picture. Sure, she had to do some not-so-sexy things, but that’s the business. To put it quite frankly, if you’re basing your expectations on what you see on TV, you’re crazy. In PR and advertising, especially entry level, you’ll be doing research, compiling lists and putting together reports — not pitching clients and designing a new campaign. I could go on about expections, but I could talk about it for a year.
  • Why did she not ask for more work? From the post, it sounded like she came to work, got her assignments, completed them and waited for someone to give her more. In fact, she should have asked for more assignments. Even better — think one step ahead and anticipate the needs of your team. This will help your get respect and ultimately, your team will trust you with bigger assignments.
  • Trying to get bad press for your ex-employer is presumptuous and could backfire. When she wrote this blog about her old company, she added at the end: “So be careful. You don’t want to end up being called out on a blog, do you?” I think this really speaks miles for itself, so I’ll hold out on saying what I really feel about this. She hurt herself so much more than she could ever hurt the company, and while social media is a great tool for learning, it’s a great tool for ruining your career, too.
  • The field is crowded. Big agencies get hundreds, if not thousands, of applicants for summer internship programs. If you don’t want to do some administrative work, I can guarantee that the next person will.

So, what do you think? Do you think this is an isolated case? What else could she have done differently?

Photo by w00kie on Flickr.

  • Share/Bookmark

  • It's difficult for me to relate. And I'm not going to defend or attack the person because I don't know who they are. And there could be all sorts of reasons. I believe that internships aren't for everyone.

    I always took an independent path, never did an internship, never really did the resume thing.

    People can forge their own paths without taking the traditional path to find success. Maybe that's what's best for them.

    For some it works, for others it doesn't. What's important is just finding what works for yourself.
  • I'd agree that there isn't one path to success for everyone. However, bad talking an old employer really shouldn't be on any route. Hopefully she is able to find something after this.
  • I think the major problem with this whole situation is that Jenavi didn't deal with her disappointment in a constructive way. Did she talk to her supervisor about taking on more responsibility? Did she think creatively about things she could be proactively working on before she was asked? Did she even ask why the "menial" tasks she was given were important? From the sounds of her rant, I'm guessing not.

    In my first agency internship, I did things like filing, updating spreadsheets, retyping documents, etc. in my first few weeks. My skills enabled me to do much more complex projects, but I had to take the little things in stride with the big things. Jenavi clearly didn't understand that small tasks are a proving ground for things like focus, accountability and attention to detail. Plus, working only two days a week, Jenavi already set herself up for a situation that doesn't fit well with ongoing projects.

    It's sad to read something like what she wrote, and think about how hard some students work toward attaining agency internships and watch the positions go to people like Jenavi. She also seems to have failed in understanding how her attitude may have played a role in her bad experience. It takes two to tango, and I'd be interested to hear what her supervisors thought of her as a productive intern.

    Very few people go through life loving everything about every job they've ever had, but successful people find a way to make the best of disappointing situations and find the value in them. I hope Jenavi is well connected outside that agency's circle or has some influential parents, because she's going to have to work very hard at defending herself to future employers.
  • You're so on. It is really sad to see her perceptions of what an ad agency is "supposed" to operate like.
blog comments powered by Disqus

About This Blog

My name is Nick Lucido and I am a public relations student at Michigan State University. For the past three years, I have been active in the PR industry with internships and PRSSA. I hope to share what I learn with you.

I also manage the PRSSA Blog and post weekly. Check it out at prssa.org/blog.

View Nick Lucido's profile on LinkedIn

PR Open Mic

RSSTwitter